Carol Platt Liebau: An "Orwellian Theory"

Sunday, December 04, 2005

An "Orwellian Theory"

Tomorrow, the Supreme Court will hear the case in which a consortium of 38 law schools are arguing that the Solomon Amendment -- which conditions the grant of federal money upon condition that law schools permit military recruiters onto campus -- is unconstitutional. Apparently, the law schools believe that they should both be able to deprive their students of the right to hear one particular point of view -- the military's -- and continue to sup at the federal trough.

Here's an excellent piece explaining how this project is the antithesis of open-mindedness and all other values that the law schools would claim to represent.

I wrote about this outrage a year ago, in reference to my alma mater, Harvard Law School. Here's an excerpt:

No one can deny that Harvard has the right to expel the military from its campus – but then it should be willing to accept the consequences, namely, the denial of federal funds. Rather than being honorable and consistent, however, Harvard was never willing to “pay for its principles” by declining the federal money when it was conditioned on military access. Apparently, Harvard will only demonstrate its moral commitment to gay rights when it won’t cost anything to do so. It’s moral vanity on the cheap.

2 Comments:

Blogger factory_peasant said...

i really don't have a problem with branches of military service on school campuses for recruiting- or other useful purposes. when i was in high school i was able to cut a bunch of classes by taking their ASVAB test. so, thank you US Army for helping me cut classes and miss a few tests that i would have otherwise failed that day because i never studied anything. YOU GUYS ROCK.

10:31 PM  
Blogger Matt Brinkman said...

The freedom of association argument that the scholls are using is straight out of the Boy Scouts of America "moreally straight" cases. Funny how I never hears Carol call this argument "An Orwellian Theory" when it cut in favor of discriminating against homosexuals.

9:15 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Google